Is gearbox oil and engine oil the same?

09 Apr.,2024

 

my first response (deleted by this rubbish website) quoted your 'filled for life'. Engineers I know scoff at the idea. One makes his money as an 'expert witness' and sees many failed gearboxes that he tells me would have lived if they'd been serviced. Mainly LandRover Discoveries it seems, but then I own one and I think he likes to try to frighten me with all of the expensive failures which require the body to come off in order to fix (gearbox, turbo, parts of the exhaust system, brake pipes etc, not to mention crank failure, oil pump/cambelt failure, suspension faults etc, why do I do it to myself...?)

Another designs print heads for a living (as far as I can tell), but is a chartered engineer and worked in automotive for years. He has a 'megaflush' done regularly on his Range Rover and his Jag. Reckons the boxes shift much better and will last much longer - not that he'll ever find out, he doesn't keep them long enough.

Common theme JLR? Maybe, dunno. My old volvo (have an XC70 too for when the Landy breaks down!) really needs a megaflush too.

I challenge your 100k is 'life' though. That's what I mean by advertising puff for the fleet managers. Even Fords have 6 digits on the odo these days...

The best-known lubricants used in a car are engine oils and transmission oils. They are used in different places in the car and fulfil different functions.

Engine oils are used directly in the combustion engine, where they protect the moving parts from wear so that the engine can perform its service for a long time. Engine oils are more heat-resistant than transmission oils, as they are permanently exposed to high temperatures when driving. However, the combustion processes in the engine cause the oil to become increasingly contaminated over time. It must therefore be changed at regular intervals in order not to lose the wear protection and damage the engine.

In transmissions, things are not nearly as hot. Here, transmission oils take on the function of wear protection, corrosion protection and friction optimisation in order to secure power transmission in the long term and to improve driving comfort with smooth transmission shifts. Transmission oils do not have to be changed as often as engine oils. But recently since the significantly increased popularity of dual-clutch transmissions, the transmission oil has also become more important to drivers. Here, change intervals of around 60,000 km are intended. This is due to the friction processes when shifting transmissions in dual clutches. The transmission oil thermally degrades much more than in a manual gearstick. And the degradation products cause the oil to age more quickly.

Is gearbox oil and engine oil the same?

What is the difference between engine oil and transmission oil?